Judge.me now features "Load More" button on All Reviews Page, when you click on "Load More" button, it allows reviews to load instead of infinite scroll (new reviews will be loaded automatically when users scroll down). 

Go to Judge.me Dashboard> Settings> Other Widgets> All Reviews Page Settings

1. Scroll down to Loading Reviews

2. Enable Load More button. 

Note: You can customize the displayed "Load More" button text. See picture below